Some people have suggested that the way to help more smokers quit is to offer treatment for a longer period--say from 6 to 8 months, as opposed to 6 to 8 weeks. Will that work?
What happens when you begin treating someone for
hypothyroidism and then have them stop taking levothyroxine? Their symptoms
return with a vengeance.
But what if you slowly wean them off levothyroxine? Their
symptoms return, bur at a slower pace. Then, when treatment stops altogether,
the symptoms return with a vengeance.
Hypothyroidism is a chronic condition that requires ongoing treatment.
Many people who smoke are self-medicating chronic underlying
conditions. The scientific literature shows that people with chronic
depression, attention deficits, memory problems, and those who are being
treated for schizophrenia have much lower rates of cessation than the rest of
the population. Let’s think for a moment about why that is true.
The scientific literature also shows that nicotine helps to
improve mood, concentration, and attention and also helps to alleviate
side-effects of anti-psychotic medications. It stands to reason that those who
have a chronic condition that is helped by nicotine will be impaired when they
give up nicotine.
It doesn’t matter whether the nicotine-dependent person
tapers down for 6 to 8 weeks or for 6 to 8 months. When nicotine
intake stops, relapse follows. Sometimes relapse begins even earlier, when the
process of tapering down triggers relapse because symptoms are not being
controlled adequately.
The Institute of Medicine’s 2001 report, “Clearing the
Smoke,” stated, “Indeed, it has been predicted that even with the most
intensive application of the most effective programs for abstinence and
cessation, at least 10 percent to 15 percent of adults in the United States
would continue to smoke.” That's not 10 to 15 percent of smokers--that's 10 to 15 percent of the entire adult population, representing between 33 and 45 million people.
The 2007 report by the Tobacco Advisory Group of the
Royal College of Physicians, “Harm reduction in nicotine addiction: Helping
people who can't quit” pointed out that some people will never be able to give
up all use of nicotine. The authors went on to say, “If nicotine could
be provided in a form that is acceptable and effective as a cigarette
substitute, millions of lives could be saved.”
Pharmaceutical nicotine products are a start, but they are
often ineffective as a cigarette substitute. The FDA has purposely kept the
nicotine dosage low in these products, in the belief that this will prevent new
addictions. Millions of people have escaped from smoking by switching to a
smoke-free alternative such as low-nitrosamine snus (a type of moist snuff),
dissolvable tobacco products, or smoke-free electronic ‘cigarettes’.